Mark 2, Luke 5 blood sacrifice? Choose good behavior to pursue the good
Guide:
CJB New Testament emphasis in bold (CJB online) or Old
Testament OJB, text I emphasize in green; NIV in magenta; footnotes to CJB in superscript sky blue and OJB; Nomads*
discussion in yellow; and my comments in gray. I may use endnotes to cite outside literature or
extensive comment.
*Participative
Sunday-school-class at UBC led by Kenny Tipton. Kenny appreciates opinion in a
continuous search for the ineluctable truth. My evolving statement about
Genesis 1:26-28,31, now from OJB, is at the end of this post.
During announcements,
Phil commented that Louisiana is a non DEI state (in a non-DEI nation) and that
UBC church has some non DEI members. DEI’s time may have passed.
Note: Eric Fulcher, on
June 30, influenced us to read the Bible intending to understand the view of life
on earth held during the writer’s era, beginning with Noah’s perception that
more than his land had flooded. By accepting that past perceptions were in
error, we, the living generation may and can act and collaborate for good
behavior in our time for ourselves and for our children and grandchildren.
In appreciation, Kenny created a one-time discussion of related NT debate about
humankind using old perceptions to consider new choices. In usual depth, Nomads,
happily joined by some from David’s class, explored Mark
(Chapter 2: 18-22) and Luke (Chapter 5: 33-39).
Chief concerns and possible insights:
1. I think the use of metaphors to cryptically express
abstract thoughts informs us that the writer is unknowing, so cannot speak
ineluctably.
a.
Much as Noah thought the
entire globe had flooded, first century writers assumed 25th century readers would
comprehend the use of wineskins.
b.
I trust neither Paul nor
Mark nor Luke as witnesses and commit to Yeshua’s influence to good behavior
2. 5500 years ago, in Genesis 1:26-28, 31, humankind
was informed that we have the power, authority, and responsibility to develop
good behavior on earth.
a.
3900 years ago, a Semite
tribe fled Ur to escape human sacrifice but continued blood sacrifice as a covenant
with their tribal God
b.
3700 years ago, a faction,
Israel codified blood sacrifice to redeem sins.
c.
2600 years ago, prophets
thought a king would emerge to unite the 12 tribes of Israel.
d.
2000 years ago, Yeshua
the Aramaic Nazarene was born a Jew
i.
He wrote no literature;
writers could construct without dispute.
ii.
Jews say Yeshua chose 11
disciples and a betrayer
iii.
In 33 CE, religious and
political enemies executed Yeshua
iv.
15 years later, Paul
wrote letters that created Christ, whose blood redeems not Jews, but afterdeath
beings, souls, chosen by the Father to believe Christ’s sacrifice on the cross.
v.
Peter created a similar
Christ but with the flexibility to improve the blood doctrine beyond the Bible –
develop Church tradition.
vi.
Apostles Yeshua had chosen
attempted to further his Church, but Yeshua himself said they miss-understood “heaven
is here”.
1.
I know of no recent resurrection
of the dead.
3. Has group or institution chosen to accept all
the opinion-development listed above, in order to go back to 5500 year old good
behavior using Yeshua’s 2000 year old reliable suggestions reported in the
Bible?
a.
I discovered Yeshua
through Nomads class and think participants may and can easily develop Yeshua’s
Church.
b.
I think UBC has always
pursued good behavior and applying an old friend’s ideas is easy, the old
friend being Yeshua, the person born in Nazareth 2000 years ago.
4. Without Eric’s sermon, Kenneth’s lesson, and the
Nomads discussion, including Russell’s legacy, I could not have written this
Biblical review.
What the Bible seems to say:
V 18. Fasting,
whether spontaneous of ceremonial, expresses humility to The God – whatever constrains
the consequences of human choice.
·
It seems
John’s disciples did not accept Yeshua as the Messiah. Jews expected a king to
unite the 12 tribes. The 12 apostles Yeshua chose never understood the recorded
cryptic lessons. Paul, self-appointed champion of non-Jews projected Yeshua’s life
onto Jewish literature, grounded in blood sacrifice to atone for sins. The
consequence is Paul’s churches, which repress Yeshua’s church. Peter’s churches
compete with Paul’s churches and there are other competitors among Christianity’s
45,000 sects in 2025. Yeshua did not write. But his message: pursue perfectly
good behavior is available to every newborn person.
·
Luke
wrote in Acts 19:1-7, about conversion of John-disciples 10 years after Yeshua
was executed: “. . . at Ephesus, where he found a few talmidim. He asked them, “Did you receive the Ruach HaKodesh when
you came to trust?” “No,” they said . . . “into what were you immersed?” “The
immersion of Yochanan,” they answered. Sha’ul said, “Yochanan practiced an immersion
in connection with turning from sin to God; but [Yochanan] told the people to
put their trust in the one who would come after him, that is, in Yeshua.” On hearing this, they were immersed into the name of the
Lord Yeshua; and when Sha’ul placed his hands on them,
the Ruach HaKodesh came upon them; so that they began speaking
in tongues and prophesying. In all, there were about
twelve of these men.” [I
do not believe the spirit of The God requires Paul’s hands and limits Yeshua’s
influence: not then, and not now.]
V 19. According
to the writer, Yeshua implied that he is the Messiah the Jews await.
V 20.
After blood and body sacrifice (“time come”) Yeshua’s disciples will fast.
V 21-22.
The cloth and wineskin metaphors imply that it is nearly impossible to enlighten
erroneous disciples: only open listeners can easily comprehend the light. Acts
19 affirms that there are listeners.
Luke
5:39 invites interpretation of “wine: as ideas and “wineskins” as persons (V 38).
The analogy does not apply to me at age 79, thanks to personal curiosity
created by Nomads-class discussions, perceiving that I have been in the
reliable influence of Yeshua since childhood deliberations to make choices. Yeshua
is a 2000 year old entity, I think discoverable by looking for the necessary
good represented as his in the Bible, and essential to us on applying his
influence in our time to us and our posterity. I think miracle works and blood
sacrifice are 1600 year old debates against 3700 year old prophecy, in order to
ignore challenging 5500 year-old political philosophy: Humankind is empowered, authorized, and responsible
to pursue necessary goodness on earth. Each person may and can personally
pursue good behavior.
That
completes my study of another wonderful Nomads discussion created and led by
Kenny in appreciation of Eric’s sermon.
Mark 2 CJB
Text follows:
2:1 After a while, Yeshua returned to K’far-Nachum.
The word spread that he was back, 2 and so many
people gathered around the house that there was no longer any room, not even in
front of the door. While he was preaching the message to them, 3 four
men came to him carrying a paralyzed man. 4 They
could not get near Yeshua because of the crowd, so they stripped the roof over
the place where he was, made an opening, and lowered the stretcher with the
paralytic lying on it. 5 Seeing their trust, Yeshua
said to the paralyzed man, “Son, your sins are forgiven.” 6 Some Torah-teachers
sitting there thought to themselves, 7 “How can
this fellow say such a thing? He is blaspheming! Who can forgive sins except
God?” 8 But immediately Yeshua, perceiving in his
spirit what they were thinking, said to them, “Why are you thinking these
things? 9 Which is easier to say to the paralyzed
man? ‘Your sins are forgiven’? or ‘Get up, pick up your stretcher and
walk’? 10 But look! I will prove to you that the
Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins.” He then said to the
paralytic, 11 “I say to you: get up, pick up your
stretcher and go home!” 12 In front of everyone the
man got up, picked up his stretcher at once and left. They were all utterly
amazed and praised God, saying, “We have never seen anything like this!”
13 Yeshua
went out again by the lake. All the crowd came to him, and he began teaching
them. 14 As he passed on from there, he saw Levi
Ben-Halfai sitting in his tax-collection booth and said to him, “Follow me!”
And he got up and followed him.
15 As
Yeshua was in Levi’s house eating, many tax-collectors and sinners were sitting
with Yeshua and his talmidim, for there were many of them among his
followers. 16 When the Torah-teachers
and the P’rushim saw that he was eating with sinners and
tax-collectors, they said to his talmidim, “Why does he eat with
tax-collectors and sinners?” 17 But, hearing the
question, Yeshua answered them, “The ones who need a doctor aren’t the healthy
but the sick. I didn’t come to call the ‘righteous’ but sinners!”
18 Also
Yochanan’s talmidim and the P’rushim were
fasting; and they came and asked Yeshua, “Why is it that Yochanan’s talmidim and
the talmidim of the P’rushim fast, but
your talmidim don’t fast?” 19 Yeshua
answered them, “Can wedding guests fast while the bridegroom is still with
them? As long as they have the bridegroom with them, fasting is out of the
question. 20 But the time will come when the
bridegroom is taken away from them; and when that day comes, they will
fast. 21 No one sews a piece of unshrunk cloth on
an old coat; if he does, the new patch tears away from the old cloth and leaves
a worse hole. 22 And no one puts new wine in old
wineskins; if he does, the wine will burst the skins, and both the wine and the
skins will be ruined. Rather, new wine is for freshly prepared wineskins.”
Note: Luke 5 has about the same story and adds, V39 Besides
that, after drinking old wine, people don’t want new; because they say, ‘The
old is good enough.’”
23 One Shabbat Yeshua
was passing through some wheat fields; and as they went along, his talmidim began
picking heads of grain. 24 The P’rushim said
to him, “Look! Why are they violating Shabbat?” 25 He
said to them, “Haven’t you ever read what David did when he and those with him
were hungry and needed food? 26 He entered the
House of God when Evyatar was cohen gadol and ate the Bread of
the Presence,” — which is forbidden for anyone to eat but the cohanim —
“and even gave some to his companions.” 27 Then he
said to them, “Shabbat was made for mankind, not mankind for Shabbat; 28 So
the Son of Man is Lord even of Shabbat.”
CJB Luke 5 follows:
5:1 One day, as Yeshua was standing on the shore of
Lake Kinneret, with the people pressing in around him in order to hear the word
of God, 2 he noticed two boats pulled up on the
beach, left there by the fishermen, who were cleaning their nets. 3 He
got into one of the boats, the one belonging to Shim‘on, and asked him to put
out a little way from shore. Then he sat down and taught the people from the
boat.
4 When
he had finished speaking, he said to Shim‘on, “Put out into deep water, and let
down your nets for a catch.” 5 Shim‘on answered,
“We’ve worked hard all night long, Rabbi, and haven’t caught a thing! But if
you say so, I’ll let down the nets.” 6 They did
this and took in so many fish that their nets began to tear. 7 So
they motioned to their partners in the other boat to come and help them; and
they came and filled both boats to the point of sinking. 8 When
he saw this, Shim‘on Kefa fell at Yeshua’s knees and said, “Get away from me,
sir, because I’m a sinner!” 9 For astonishment had
seized him and everyone with him at the catch of fish they had taken, 10 and
likewise both Ya‘akov and Yochanan, Shim‘on’s partners. “Don’t be frightened,”
Yeshua said to Shim‘on, “from now on you will be catching men — alive!” 11 And
as soon as they had beached their boats, they left everything behind and followed
him.
12 Once,
when Yeshua was in one of the towns, there came a man completely covered
with tzara‘at. On seeing Yeshua, he fell on his face and begged
him, “Sir, if you are willing, you can make me clean.” 13 Yeshua
reached out his hand and touched him, saying, “I am willing!
Be cleansed!” Immediately the tzara‘at left him. 14 Then
Yeshua warned him not to tell anyone. “Instead, as a testimony to the people,
go straight to the cohen and make an offering for your
cleansing, as Moshe commanded.” 15 But the news
about Yeshua kept spreading all the more, so that huge crowds would gather to
listen and be healed of their sicknesses. 16 However,
he made a practice of withdrawing to remote places in order to pray.
17 One
day when Yeshua was teaching, there were P’rushim and Torah-teachers
present who had come from various villages in the Galil and Y’hudah, also from
Yerushalayim; and the power of Adonai the Lord was with him
to heal the sick. 18 Some men came carrying a
paralyzed man lying on a bed. They wanted to bring him inside and lay him in
front of Yeshua, 19 but they couldn’t find a way to
get him in because of the crowd. So they went up onto the roof and lowered him
on his mattress through the tiles into the middle of the gathering, right in
front of Yeshua. 20 When Yeshua saw their trust, he
said, “Friend, your sins are forgiven you.” 21 The Torah-teachers
and the P’rushim began thinking, “Who is this fellow that
speaks such blasphemies? Who can forgive sin except God?” 22 But
Yeshua, knowing what they were thinking, answered, “Why are you turning over
such thoughts in your hearts? 23 Which is easier to
say? ‘Your sins are forgiven you’? or ‘Get up and walk’? 24 But
look! I will prove to you that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive
sins.” He then said to the paralytic, “I say to you: get up, pick up your
mattress and go home!” 25 Immediately, in front of
everyone, he stood up, picked up what he had been lying on, and went home
praising God. 26 Amazement seized them all, and
they made a b’rakhah to God; they were awestruck, saying, “We
have seen extraordinary things today.”
27 Later
Yeshua went out and saw a tax-collector named Levi sitting in his
tax-collection booth; and he said to him, “Follow me!” 28 He
got up, left everything and followed him.
29 Levi
gave a banquet at his house in Yeshua’s honor, and there was a large group of
tax-collectors and others at the table with them. 30 The P’rushim and
their Torah-teachers protested indignantly against his talmidim,
saying, “Why do you eat and drink with tax-collectors and sinners?” 31 It
was Yeshua who answered them: “The ones who need a doctor aren’t the healthy
but the sick. 32 I have not come to call the
‘righteous,’ but rather to call sinners to turn to God from their sins.”
33 Next
they said to him, “Yochanan’s talmidim are always fasting
and davvening, and likewise the talmidim of
the P’rushim; but yours go on eating and drinking.” 34 Yeshua
said to them, “Can you make wedding guests fast while the bridegroom is still
with them? 35 The time will come when the
bridegroom will be taken away from them; and when that time comes, they will
fast.” 36 Then he gave them an illustration: “No
one tears a piece from a new coat and puts it on an old one; if he does, not
only will the new one continue to rip, but the piece from the new will not
match the old. 37 Also, no one puts new wine into
old wineskins; if he does, the new wine will burst the skins and be spilled,
and the skins too will be ruined. 38 On the
contrary, new wine must be put into freshly prepared wineskins. 39 Besides that, after drinking old
wine, people don’t want new; because they say, ‘The old is good enough.’”
[Genesis
1:26-28, 31 OJB:
I
read to consider and apply perhaps 5500 year old Sumerian political philosophy,
religiously referenced by Semite (pre-Israel) scribes of 3900 years ago, in
Genesis 1:26-28, in my paraphrase and extension to law:
Female-and-male-human-being may and can
choose to practice the power, authority, and responsibility
to pursue necessary goodness and constrain wickedness on earth. Civic
citizens may and can use the rule of law to develop statutory justice.
Political
and religious philosopher Yeshua affirmed Genesis 1:26-28, 31, contributing
ideas in each Matthew 18:18 (no peace-power above humankind), Matthew 19:3-8
(mutual spousal-loyalty), Matthew 5:48 (in good behavior, pursue personal
perfection, which also affirms Deuteronomy 18:13), 19:4-6 (don’t divide/lessen
goodness), John 10:34 (non-wicked humans are gods -- facing death, as in Psalm
82:1-7), and in other direct dialogue, such as “go and sin no more”. Psalm 82
says nothing about resurrection.
Discussion
I think Genesis 1:26-28, 31 informs humankind to flourish in
necessary goodness rather than accommodate badness and allow evil.
Quoting OJB below,
And G-d said, Let Us make
man in Our tzelem, after Our demut: and let them have dominion over the fish of
the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the
earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth upon ha’aretz (the earth).
So G-d created humankind in
His own tzelem, in the tzelem Elohim (image of G-d) created He him; zachar
(male) and nekevah (female) created He them.
And G-d blessed them, and
G-d said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue
it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air,
and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth. See note, below.
Accepting
the power, authority, and responsibility to rule on earth is human
being (verb). Reliable human-beings choose necessary goodness to actual
reality. The God affirms the goodness in V 31:
And G-d saw every thing that He had made, and, behold, it
was tov me’od (very good).
Note: OJB uses “Elohim” in Genesis 1 and 2,
excepting “G-d” in 1:24-31. V 27 seems to equate the two entities. Septuagint uses “ὁ θεὸς”, or God throughout
Genesis 1. I use “The God, or whatever constrains human choice”, hoping to
express humility.
Since monotheism is a human
construct, I use the phrase, “The God, whatever it may be”, to express objection
to any doctrinal God yet reserve humility to ineluctable evidence and remaining
unknowns about what constrains the consequences of human choices.]